| 1 | System Voltage and MCOV | Match the arrester's maximum continuous operating voltage (MCOV) to the system's highest continuous line-to-ground voltage and grounding method. | For a 12 kV-class distribution system, commonly evaluated MCOV values may be around 7.65–10.2 kV, depending on system grounding. The final value must be confirmed by a protection study. | Verify phase-to-ground connection, neutral grounding, temporary overvoltage exposure, and available mounting space before ordering. | Incorrect MCOV selection can cause premature thermal failure or insufficient protection, increasing replacement and outage costs. |
| 2 | Protection Level | Compare residual voltage at the specified discharge current with the equipment insulation withstand level, rather than comparing nominal voltage alone. | For medium-voltage equipment, the arrester protection level should provide a practical insulation coordination margin below the protected equipment's impulse withstand level. A commonly used engineering target is at least 15% margin, subject to the applicable standard and study. | Install the arrester as close as practical to the protected transformer, cable termination, or switchgear, using short and straight connections. | Better voltage coordination reduces the probability of transformer, motor, and switchgear damage during lightning or switching events. |
| 3 | Discharge Current and Energy Capability | Compare nominal discharge current, high-current impulse capability, line discharge class, and thermal energy rating. | Distribution applications frequently use 5 kA or 10 kA nominal discharge current ratings. Substation and high-energy applications may require higher energy capability and a higher line discharge class. | Check system fault current, repetitive switching surges, cable lengths, capacitor banks, and transformer characteristics before selecting the energy class. | A higher energy rating may cost more initially but can reduce the risk of catastrophic arrester failure and unplanned downtime. |
| 4 | Housing Material and Pollution Performance | Compare polymeric and porcelain housings, creepage distance, pollution severity, UV resistance, hydrophobicity, and mechanical strength. | Polymeric housings are generally lighter and more resistant to shattering; porcelain housings may be selected where established mechanical or site practices require them. Creepage distance must suit the site's pollution level. | Confirm clearances, mounting orientation, altitude correction, salt or industrial pollution exposure, and local mechanical loading. | Housing choice affects transport, installation labor, cleaning frequency, weathering performance, and end-of-life handling. |
| 5 | Applicable Standards and Test Evidence | Request evidence of compliance with the relevant edition of IEC 60099-4, IEEE C62.11, or the purchaser's required national standard. | Review routine-test records, type-test reports, reference conditions, declared tolerances, and the exact product configuration covered by the test report. | Ensure terminal dimensions, mounting hardware, line and earth connectors, and enclosure interfaces match the project drawings and local electrical codes. | Complete documentation reduces approval delays, warranty disputes, and the cost of replacing non-compliant equipment. |
| 6 | Total Delivered Cost | Compare purchase price, freight, insurance, import duties, taxes, testing, spare parts, and commissioning—not only the quoted unit price. | For international procurement, logistics and import charges can add approximately 10–30% to the quoted equipment value, depending on shipment size, destination, Incoterms, and customs treatment. | Confirm packaging dimensions, gross weight, lifting points, delivery sequence, storage conditions, and port or site handling requirements. | Use a five- to ten-year total-cost model that includes expected replacement, inspection, outage exposure, and disposal costs. |
| 7 | Installation Labor and Accessories | Compare whether brackets, disconnectors, surge counters, grading rings, terminals, and earth connectors are included. | Accessories and site labor can represent a meaningful share of installed cost, especially for retrofit work, elevated platforms, or live-line restrictions. Obtain a project-specific installation quotation. | Provide a low-impedance earth connection, maintain manufacturer-specified phase spacing and clearances, and keep lead lengths as short as possible. | Complete accessory packages reduce field modification, installation errors, commissioning delays, and future troubleshooting time. |
| 8 | Monitoring and Failure Indication | Compare visual indicators, leakage-current monitoring, surge counters, disconnector operation, remote contacts, and integration with the substation monitoring system. | Basic distribution installations may use visual inspection or a disconnector, while critical substations may justify continuous leakage-current monitoring and alarm contacts. | Provide instrument transformer, control-cable, communication, and panel space where remote monitoring is required. | Monitoring can increase initial cost but helps identify deterioration before a failure causes an outage or collateral equipment damage. |
| 9 | Inspection and Maintenance Plan | Compare recommended inspection intervals, leakage-current limits, cleaning procedures, torque checks, thermal imaging requirements, and replacement criteria. | A practical program may include visual inspection at least annually and after major storm events, with interval adjustments based on site risk, pollution, and utility procedures. De-energized testing must follow approved safety procedures. | Ensure safe access, isolation, grounding, and sufficient working clearance for inspection and replacement activities. | Routine visual and thermal inspections are usually less expensive than emergency replacement after a failed arrester damages adjacent equipment. |
| 10 | Warranty, Delivery, and Spare Strategy | Compare warranty duration, defect response time, technical support, factory lead time, minimum order quantity, and spare-unit availability. | For critical sites, define acceptable lead times, batch traceability, serial-number records, and a recommended spare ratio based on the site risk assessment and installed population. | Store spare arresters in clean, dry conditions and protect polymeric housings from mechanical damage, contamination, and prolonged exposure to direct sunlight before installation. | Local or regional spares can reduce outage duration and expedited freight costs, particularly where replacement requires planned switching or specialist labor. |